I found this recipe online and I had to try it out. A moist, delicious, and most importantly endlessly creative cake with only 3 ingredients? It had to be a scam.
The person who posted this recipe claims she got it from an Amish woman, which means that you don’t need any fancy mixers to prepare it. So I sent my mother out to get the 3 ingredients and, curious to see if it would actually make something, she obliged. The 3 ingredients are:
3 large eggs
1 box cake mix (any flavor)
1 can pie filling (any flavor)
I chose yellow cake mix and peach pie filling, but you can actually choose, for example, yellow cake mix and cherry pie filling and the cake will come out pink! Check it out:
You can also choose blueberry pie filling and the cake comes out blue or chocolate cake mix and the cake comes out, well, chocolate.
The recipe claims that the cake comes out so moist and so delicious that you don’t even need to frost it.
To Find Out All The Yummy Ingredients And The Step By Step Directions To Follow for this Delicious recipes, Please Head On Over To Next Page Or Open button.
NEXT PAGE>>>
Size of pan and also pie filling?
9×13
I used A bundt pan and drizzled A glaze on it with confection sugar and water
I would guess the standard 15 ounce can of pie filling is what’s required. I would personally use an 11×9 or a 10×10 inch pan.
Do you have to flour the pan?
Comes out better
It’s easier to remove if you do.
do you mix everything together before baking the cake?
Yes. You mix all three ingredients until blended before pouring into baking dish.
Would be nice to have the full instructions.
Just mix together and bake as per cake box instructions
So, then, the recipe says you put the three ingredients into a bowl, mix them well, and bake for 35 minutes at 350 degrees. The whole thing from prep to clean-up took me 10 minutes
You bake the ingredients in a bowl!!?
😂 hopefully not. But I see what you mean, it’s a bit misleading and terribly funny.
I guess you use the cake mix dry?
No, it says blend ingredients well.
Do you pour ise cake mix dry not go by directions on the box?
What are the instructions??
The instructions are: blend ingredients well and bake @350 degrees for 25-30 minutes. I would suggest using the toothpick method to make sure it’s properly baked through.
Insert pick in center of cake, if it comes out dry the cake is finished. If it comes out gooey, bake another 5-10 minutes.
If you have ever bald you should be smart enough to figure it out duh
Bald?????
Usually we put oil and water in the mix–but here there’s nothing about that. So what is the latest update on this recipe?
Just those 3 ingredients, nothing else.
I heated up my 2 cans of peaches in a pot with a little cinnamon half stick of butter poured them in a 9×13 pan then I poured the dry cake in on top sprinkled a little cinnamon and covered with pat’s of butter and caked till bubbling maybe 25-30 minutes in 350.
Did u mix it together
Just put the three Ingredients in a bowl and mix very well. Don’t add anything else. The butter pecan cake mix with apple pie filling is really good. We ate it plain, but adding ice cream would be great as would some frosting.
If you hit the next page button the recipe instructions is there
no eggs ??
3large eggs
NO eggs
Yes, it states three large eggs as one of the three ingredients in the recipe.
3 large eggs
1 box cake mix
1 can pie filling.
My best guess would be the 15 ounce can of filling, a standard size cake mix (not the small single layer size) and as for a baking dish, probably an 11×9 or a 10×10 square.
I make it with devils food cake mix cherrie pie filling and walnuts. Just pie filling on bottom of pan top it with dry cake mix and pour. Melted butter over it add walnuts and bake
That’s a dump cake. This one is different. No layering. You mix all the ingredients together, then you put in 9×13 pan and bake at 350 for 30 minutes.
I put my peach pie filling in my blender for seconds and added that to my cake mix (yellow) and 3 eggs. Buttered a 9 x 13 casserole dish. Baked at 350 for 30 mins It was so moist and delicious. Will be baking another one trying another pie filling. Oh, we added cool whip on top when we ate it
It is so delicious. You will love it. Super easy three ingredients.
I did spice cake with apple pie filling. Delicious.
Perfect! This is the answer I was searching for.
What size can of pie filling.
Love this cake – yellow cake & peach. Great with strawberry & cool whip!
There is no picture of baked cake
Scary reading these comments (when the picture shows the ingredients) and know they vote, drive, etc.
Bahahaha! Right?!
I wouldn’t think an Amish woman would use a store bought cake mix or canned pie filling.
People it’s not that hard to understand there’s only 3 ingredients. Pretty simple
I have read these instructions from the top,……what seems to be the problem with some of these folks…..is it to simple for some….just do as it says I will be baking this tomorrow….this is as simple as Angel foood cake mix na can of crushed pineapple with the juice…simple… 2 ingredients….trust these recipes …they’re simple….thank you…
I have made this several times with chocolate cake mix, 3 eggs, and cherry pie filling. Mix well with mixer. Spray 9×13 pan and bake 35 min. Delicious a very moist cake
I also have added a teaspoon almond extract.
We live around Amush, and my husband has worked for them for over 35 years. Yes they buy box cake mixes and can pie mix.. They have Amish salvage stores around us and the Amish buy everything we do…
Please tell me the comments are a joke. How hard is it to follow the author’s instructions?!?! The comments are made up right? 🤦🏻♀️
Thank you all for the comments! I had a hard day today and reading all of the responses to this post has me crying laughing 😂😂 …
I’ve made this with chocolate cake and cherry pie filling. Delicious
I thought I read somewhere that someone used an angel food cake mix and pineapple. Did I imagine that? Did they drain the pineapple?
I have made the angel food & pineapple cake. No, do not drain the pineapple juice. Mix the cake mix and pineapple juice together . That’s what makes it moist. I topped it with Cool Whip or real whip cream and a marshchino cherry on top.
Angel food cake mix and can of crushed pineapple. Mix together and bake. You did not imagine it. DELICIOUS
Anyone use lemon pie filling?