If you’re like us and, this time of year, constantly searching for that perfect summer dessert, we may have just found it for you. Cheesecake can be a year-round staple, but turning that into a cheesecake-pudding hybrid is truly a feat, and one that you’ll want to immediately try out after seeing this recipe. We give you: cream cheese lemonade pie. All the creaminess of a cheesecake, but less fussy and stuffed to the brim with the sweet and tart lemonade goodness we all know and love.
So we mentioned there’s a pudding element of this dish, but that’s not all. Along with using lemon pudding to thicken things up and offer some structure to the pie, we also used frozen lemonade concentrate to amp up the flavor and truly turn this into a lemonade dessert.
The result is an über lemony confection that will cool you off on even the hottest days and will have you craving more once you’ve finished that first slice. Thankfully, the recipe is super simple, so you can whip up more whenever the craving hits! How’s that for the perfect summer dessert?!
INGREDIENTS
2 (8 oz.) packages cream cheese, room temperature
1 (5 oz.) can evaporated milk
1 (3.4 oz.) box instant lemon pudding mix
3/4 cup frozen lemonade concentrate
1 graham cracker pie crust
Lemon zest or whipped cream, optional
PREPARATION
Combine evaporated milk and pudding mix in a medium bowl and beat on low speed for 2-3 minutes, or until thick.
In a separate bowl or mixer, beat cream cheese until light and airy, then mix in lemonade concentrate. Once fully incorporated, mix in pudding mixture.
Transfer filling mixture to pie crust, then place in refrigerator and chill for 4-6 hours, or overnight.
Slice, serve and enjoy!
Need to double check, evaporated or condensed milk?
I checked other recipes for Cream Cheese Lemonade Pie and they too called for 5 oz of evaporated milk.
The pudding will thicken the filling.
can I use chocolate pudding instead.?
With lemonade?
Do you add water to the frozen lemonade
No!!
Can this firm enough to be made in a cheese cake springform pan?
i added fresh blueberries I had just picked right before I put it in the crust and then added a few more on top for garnish and it was fabulous
I made tonight. Taste seems OK. Not as lemony as I thought. Wish I would have added lemon zest to the mix.Used sugar free pudding as my husband is diabetic. I think it will be good. Reminds me of lemon ice box pies my grandmother used to make with sweetened condensed milk, eggs and lemon juice. I don’t know the amounts of each but think this will be a great summertime dessert!
Don’t have frozen lemonade concentrate. Can I use lemon juice?
I made this pie. I could not find frozen lemonade so I used frozen limeade and my husband loved this pie. His favorite pie is lemon but he really liked this one.